Non-Discogenic Sciatica
Overview
The most common cause of sciatica is a herniated disk that puts pressure on the nerve roots, typically at the L4/L5 or L5/S1 level. This condition is characterized by lower back pain that extends to the buttock, back of the thigh, and the front and side of the lower leg.
In some cases, the pain can even reach the foot. Approximately 90% of sciatica cases are attributed to herniated disks and other degenerative issues in the lumbosacral region.
Misdiagnosis and Unnecessary Surgery
Despite exhibiting mild to moderate disc disease on imaging, some patients with classic sciatica may receive a misdiagnosis related to disc issues. Unfortunately, this can result in unnecessary surgical procedures.
It is of utmost importance to explore alternative causes when patients continue to experience sciatica symptoms with normal or slightly altered lumbar images, including non-spinal origins.
Non-Discogenic Sciatica (NDS): Clinical Presentation
In patients with non-discogenic sciatica (NDS), the neurological examination often reveals the absence of Lasègue’s sign, a positive Tinel’s sign with radiation along the sciatic nerve (SN) distribution, and tenderness upon deep palpation in the infragluteal region between the ischial tuberosity and the greater trochanteric area.
Frequent causes of non-discogenic sciatica (NDS) involve traumatic, inflammatory, tumoral, vascular, and gynecological factors. Conditions like schwannomas, neurofibromas, and malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors can exert pressure on the sciatic nerve (SN). NDS can also be mimicked by metastasis from prostate cancer and uncommon conditions like extradural hemangioma.
These cases typically manifest with initial sciatic pain, along with neurological symptoms like weakness, changes in gait, reduced reflexes, tingling sensations, and abnormal sensations, which resemble discogenic sciatica.
Among the causes of sciatica, extra-uterine endometriosis has emerged as a prominent factor, particularly affecting the right side. This condition, referred to as cyclical sciatic, involves pain that aligns with the menstrual cycle. In cases of extra-uterine endometriosis, MRI scans demonstrate the presence of intense T1 and T2 signals.
Non-discogenic sciatica (NDS) is an infrequent condition that is often overlooked due to its similarity to more common causes of sciatica. In this study, we present a series of six patients treated at the Division of Neurosurgery at HUGG between 2010 and 2018. Treatment approaches varied, including surgery with lesion excision, incisional biopsy followed by radiotherapy, and drug therapy.
In a study reported by literature, the patients experienced significant sciatica symptoms, including persistent pain, tenderness in the buttock area, and a positive Tinel’s sign along the course of the sciatic nerve. It was observed a deep-seated lesions without apparent masses.
NDS, a form of sciatica not related to disc issues, is primarily documented in case reports, often involving tumor cases. However, there is currently no established standardized clinical approach for NDS.
To prevent misdiagnosis, it is vital to identify symptoms and signs associated with discogenic causes and establish a connection between physical examination and imaging findings.
Indicators of nerve root compression in individuals with lumbar disc herniation include localized pain following dermatomal patterns, leg coldness, heightened pain during specific activities, muscle weakness, limited finger-floor distance, absent reflexes, and a positive straight leg raise test.
However, there is a lack of literature addressing the specific neurological examination for non-discogenic sciatica (NDS).
Patients with endometriosis experienced cyclical sciatica during menstruation, indicating a gynecological cause. Extra-uterine endometriosis is a common contributor to gynecological non-discogenic sciatica (NDS).
The mechanism behind sciatica development in these cases is still debated, with theories ranging from pelvic peritoneal pain referral to perineural spread affecting the lumbosacral plexus. Imaging studies have shown compromised sciatic nerve (SN) in many cases. MRI confirmed SN enlargement, and hormonal therapy was effective, consistent with existing literature.
Piriformis Syndrome and NDS
The literature presents differing opinions on whether piriformis syndrome is a possible cause of sciatica. In one case, initial symptom relief was observed after a piriformis injection; however, further examination revealed stage IV sarcoma instead of piriformis syndrome.
Given the similarities in clinical presentation between tumoral and non-tumoral non-discogenic sciatica (NDS), it is advisable to conduct an MRI of the gluteus region for individuals suspected of having piriformis syndrome to exclude more serious underlying conditions.
Radiological studies in the English literature have assessed the role of MRI in diagnosing non-discogenic sciatica (NDS). Literature has reported correlated histopathological cases with imaging findings, identifying the main causes of NDS. The importance of combining clinical and MRI findings for accurate diagnoses has been emphasized.
Authors have cautioned against overreliance on lumbosacral MRI results as disc-related findings may be incorrectly implicated as the cause of symptoms. In our study, abnormalities observed on lumbosacral MRI in two patients were considered insufficient to explain the severity of symptoms and neurological signs.
Literature has reported unsuccessful surgical treatment for lumbosacral disc disease, revealing a sciatic notch schwannoma. Another study reported lumbar arthrodesis, which failed to improve symptoms in a patient later diagnosed with a low-grade sarcoma. Tumor resection provided long-term pain relief.
Clinical findings such as sciatic pain, positive Tinel’s sign, and deep infragluteal tenderness prompted a gluteal MRI for accurate diagnosis. These findings strongly indicate non-discogenic sciatica (NDS) and highlight the importance of gluteal imaging when lumbar spine imaging is inconclusive.
Further investigation with a pelvic MRI is recommended if gluteal MRI results are negative. Misdiagnosis of non-discogenic sciatica as discogenic is common, even when lumbosacral MRI results are inconclusive.
Conclusion
When a patient with sciatica reports sitting-related pain, displays a positive Tinel’s sign, experiences marked tenderness upon deep infragluteal palpation, and presents inconclusive lumbosacral MRI findings, it is advisable to refer them for a gluteal ± pelvic MRI.
This recommendation applies irrespective of the presence of a detectable mass.
Do you have more questions?
What is non-discogenic sciatica (NDS)?
NDS is a type of sciatica that is not caused by disc herniation or degenerative disc disease. Instead, it is often due to other conditions like tumors, trauma, inflammation, or gynecological issues.
How can I tell if my sciatica is non-discogenic?
NDS often presents with a positive Tinel’s sign, tenderness in the infragluteal region, and the absence of Lasègue’s sign. It may also be associated with conditions like tumors or endometriosis
Can NDS be mistaken for discogenic sciatica?
Yes, because the symptoms can be very similar, including pain, weakness, and changes in reflexes. However, imaging and a thorough clinical examination can help distinguish between the two.
Why is it important to differentiate between discogenic and non-discogenic sciatica?
Proper diagnosis is crucial to avoid unnecessary surgeries and to ensure appropriate treatment for the underlying cause, which may not be related to spinal disc issues.
What imaging studies are most helpful in diagnosing NDS?
MRI of the gluteal and pelvic regions, along with targeted imaging of the sciatic nerve, can be more helpful than lumbar spine MRI when diagnosing NDS.
What are the most common causes of NDS?
Common causes include tumors (e.g., schwannomas, neurofibromas), trauma, inflammatory conditions, and gynecological issues like endometriosis.
Can endometriosis cause sciatica?
Yes, extra-uterine endometriosis can lead to cyclical sciatica, especially affecting the right side, correlating with the menstrual cycle.
Why might a standard lumbar MRI miss NDS?
NDS often involves regions outside the lumbar spine, such as the pelvis or gluteal region, which may not be included in a standard lumbar MRI.
What role does MRI play in diagnosing NDS?
MRI helps identify the underlying cause of NDS by revealing abnormalities in the sciatic nerve or surrounding tissues that are not visible on standard lumbar spine MRI.
What is a Tinel’s sign, and why is it relevant to NDS?
Tinel’s sign is a tingling sensation felt when tapping over a nerve. In NDS, a positive Tinel’s sign along the sciatic nerve can indicate nerve involvement unrelated to disc issues.
What should I do if my sciatica doesn’t improve with standard treatment?
If symptoms persist despite treatment, further evaluation for non-discogenic causes, including a comprehensive neurological exam and specialized imaging, is warranted.
Can NDS be treated with surgery?
Surgery may be an option if a specific lesion or tumor is identified, but treatment varies depending on the underlying cause and may include radiotherapy or drug therapy.
How can I prevent misdiagnosis of sciatica?
Ensure a thorough evaluation that includes both clinical examination and appropriate imaging. If lumbar MRI is inconclusive, ask about additional imaging of the gluteal and pelvic areas.
Is there a risk of permanent damage with NDS?
Depending on the cause, there could be a risk of permanent nerve damage, especially if the condition involves a tumor or significant nerve compression.
What is the prognosis for patients with NDS?
The prognosis varies depending on the underlying cause. Early and accurate diagnosis is critical for effective treatment and a better outcome.
Can tumors cause NDS?
Yes, tumors such as schwannomas, neurofibromas, and malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors can compress the sciatic nerve, leading to NDS.
Can NDS be caused by vascular issues?
Yes, vascular abnormalities such as hemangiomas can cause compression of the sciatic nerve, leading to NDS.
What is the significance of a deep infragluteal tenderness?
Deep infragluteal tenderness is a clinical sign that may indicate NDS, particularly in the absence of lumbar spine abnormalities.
How does cyclical sciatica differ from regular sciatica?
Cyclical sciatica is associated with the menstrual cycle and is often caused by endometriosis affecting the sciatic nerve, whereas regular sciatica typically results from spinal disc issues.
Can hormone therapy help with NDS?
Hormonal therapy may be effective, especially in cases of NDS related to endometriosis, as it can reduce the symptoms associated with the menstrual cycle.
What is piriformis syndrome, and how is it related to NDS?
Piriformis syndrome involves the piriformis muscle compressing the sciatic nerve, which can mimic NDS. However, it’s crucial to rule out other serious causes like tumors.
Is there a standardized approach to diagnosing NDS?
Currently, there is no standardized approach, but combining clinical examination with targeted imaging studies is essential for accurate diagnosis.
Can NDS resolve on its own?
While some cases may improve with conservative treatment, others, particularly those involving tumors or significant nerve compression, may require more aggressive intervention.
Can physical therapy help with NDS?
Physical therapy may provide relief, particularly if the sciatica is due to muscle or soft tissue issues. However, it may be less effective for NDS caused by tumors or vascular issues.
What should I expect during a neurological examination for sciatica?
The examination will include tests for reflexes, strength, sensation, and specific signs like Tinel’s and Lasègue’s to help determine the cause of your sciatica.
I am fellowship trained in joint replacement surgery, metabolic bone disorders, sports medicine and trauma. I specialize in total hip and knee replacements, and I have personally written most of the content on this page.
You can see my full CV at my profile page.
