Turf Toe: A Comprehensive Guide for Patients and Athletes
Turf toe is a sprain of the first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint, caused by forceful hyperextension of the big toe. Though the name may sound minor, the condition can severely impact athletes, especially those in high-impact sports like football, soccer, basketball, and wrestling. Left untreated, it may lead to long-term functional loss, pain, joint stiffness, and deformity.
Anatomy and Biomechanics
The first MTP joint is a complex structure comprised of four bones, nine ligaments, and three key muscular attachments. Its stability largely depends on soft tissues—especially the plantar plate, a thickened part of the joint capsule that is the primary stabilizer. Other important structures include the collateral ligaments, flexor hallucis brevis (FHB), and sesamoid bones, which all work together to support flexion, prevent excessive extension, and absorb forces during motion​
​
Mechanism of Injury
Turf toe injuries occur during activities that forcefully hyperextend the great toe. The classic mechanism involves axial loading on a plantar-flexed foot with the heel lifted and the toe fixed against the ground. This frequently happens on rigid artificial turf when an athlete plants the forefoot and a load drives the toe into dorsiflexion (upward bending), overstretching or tearing the plantar structures​
Additionally, valgus forces or compression can worsen the injury, especially if the force includes medial deviation—leading to hallux valgus deformities.
Classification
Turf toe injuries are categorized based on the severity of the ligamentous damage:
Grade: Description, Treatment – Return to Play (RTP)
Grade I: Stretching of the plantar structures, mild swelling – Symptomatic care (RICE, taping) 3–5 days​
Grade II: Partial tear, moderate swelling, decreased motion – Immobilization (boot), restricted activity 2–4 weeks​
Grade III: Complete rupture, instability, major swelling – Often surgical repair 4–16+ weeks​
​
Risk Factors
- Playing on artificial turf (especially earlier generations)
- Lightweight, flexible shoes with insufficient support
- Higher athlete weight
- Playing key positions like running back or wide receiver
- History of prior MTP injury
Diagnosis
Physical Examination
Evaluation includes:
- Inspecting swelling, bruising, and deformity
- Assessing active and passive toe range of motion
- Applying varus/valgus and drawer tests to detect instability
- Palpating sesamoid region for localized pain
Imaging
- X-rays (AP, lateral, oblique): Assess sesamoid migration, bony flecks (avulsions)
- Stress radiographs: Reveal dorsal translation of the toe
- MRI: Offers a detailed view of soft tissue injury including plantar plate, sesamoid complex, and cartilage​
​
Initial and Sideline Management
If instability is suspected during a game, the athlete should be pulled from play immediately. Key on-field assessments include dorsiflexion resistance and valgus/varus stress testing. If dislocation is noted, and imaging isn’t immediately available, closed reduction can be attempted with subsequent immobilization​.
Treatment Options
Non-Surgical (Grades I–II)
- RICE Protocol: Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation
- NSAIDs: To reduce pain and inflammation
- Immobilization: Boot, cast, or stiff-soled shoe to limit dorsiflexion
- Orthotics: Carbon fiber turf toe plates or Morton’s extension to restrict motion (see page 5 diagram in the 2010 article)​
- Rehabilitation: Gradual progression of weight-bearing and strengthening over 6–10 weeks (See Table 4 in the article)​
.
Surgical Treatment (Grade III)
Surgery is reserved for:
- Complete plantar plate rupture
- Sesamoid retraction or fracture
- Joint instability or loose bodies
- Chronic deformities (hallux valgus or rigidus)
- Failure of conservative care
Techniques include:
- End-to-end capsular repair
- Suture anchors into the phalanx if retraction is present
- Sesamoidectomy (partial or total) in severe cases, often accompanied by tendon transfers like abductor hallucis to maintain function​
​
.
Post-Operative Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation after surgery is longer and includes four stages:
- Weeks 0–6: Non-weightbearing, immobilized in a boot, passive ROM begins at 1 week
- Weeks 6–10: Progressive weight-bearing, gait normalization, aerobic and core exercises
- Weeks 10–12: Functional training (ladder drills, box jumps), continued protection
- Weeks 12–20: Advanced sport-specific training, return to non-contact, then full play​
.
Return-to-Play and Long-Term Outcomes
Non-Operative:
- Most athletes with grade I injuries return within a week
- Grade II injuries may take 2–6 weeks
- 70–100% of players resume sport, but performance may be reduced if not fully healed​
​
.
Operative:
- Average RTP: 3.5 months
- 70–90% of athletes return to play, though some retire early
- Risk of persistent pain, stiffness, and 17% recurrence rate with high-grade injuries
- Proper timing of surgery affects outcomes—delays over 6 months increase complication risks​
.
Conclusion
Turf toe is a serious and often underestimated condition that can derail athletic careers if not appropriately diagnosed and managed. Outcomes depend heavily on injury grading, promptness of treatment, and adherence to rehabilitation protocols. With appropriate care, most athletes—especially with low-grade injuries—can return to pre-injury levels of performance. However, high-grade injuries, particularly those requiring surgery, demand a more prolonged recovery and careful progression to minimize the risk of long-term disability.
Do you have more questions?
Q. What is turf toe?
A. Turf toe is a sprain of the ligaments around the big toe joint, often resulting from hyperextension during sports activities.
Q. What causes turf toe?
A. Turf toe is caused by excessive upward bending of the big toe joint, typically during push-off movements in sports played on artificial surfaces.
Q. Which sports commonly lead to turf toe?
A. Turf toe is commonly seen in football, soccer, basketball, and other sports that involve running and quick direction changes.
Q. What are the symptoms of turf toe?
A. Symptoms include pain, swelling, and limited movement at the base of the big toe.
Q. How is turf toe diagnosed?
A. Diagnosis is based on a physical exam, patient history, and may include imaging studies like X-rays or MRI to assess severity.
Q. How is turf toe treated?
A. Treatment typically involves rest, ice, compression, elevation (RICE), and immobilization. Severe cases may require physical therapy or surgery.
Q. When should an athlete return to sports after turf toe?
A. Return to sports depends on the severity of the injury and usually occurs after pain subsides and range of motion and strength are restored.
Q. Can turf toe become a chronic issue?
A. Yes, if not properly treated, turf toe can lead to chronic pain and joint instability.
Q. What is the long-term outlook for someone with turf toe?
A. With appropriate treatment, most people recover fully, though severe cases may have lingering stiffness or discomfort.
Q. How can turf toe be prevented?
A. Prevention includes wearing proper footwear, using orthotics for support, and strengthening foot and toe muscles.
Dr. Mo Athar
