Outcomes following 10-Year mark of Spine Patient Outcomes

Research Trial for Intervertebral Disc Herniation

A Path Through History

  • Goldthwait and Osgood identified disc protrusion as the cause of lower extremity paresis in 1911.
  • In 1929, two patients with complaints of back and leg pain were surgically treated by Dandy, an American neurosurgeon.
  • In 1932, Barr, an orthopedic surgeon, and Mixter, a neurosurgeon, reported the first intentional discectomy for treating disc herniation. During this time, the use of surgical discectomy increased rapidly, which led to questioning of the effectiveness of surgical treatment.
  • During the 1980s, Weber and Hakelius demonstrated that nonoperative treatment could lead to significant improvement in many patients, and the debate over surgical versus nonoperative interventions began as a result.
  • The establishment of the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial (SPORT) was driven by the need for a comprehensive study with prospectively collected data.

SPORT yielded evidence regarding the suitability of spinal surgery in patients and also provided data for comparing surgical treatment with nonoperative treatment. SPORT’s data has shed light on the appropriate role of surgical intervention in managing intervertebral disc herniation (IDH), degenerative spondylolisthesis (DS), and lumbar spinal stenosis (SpS).

According to the literature, the OBS cohort analysis for intervertebral disc herniation (IDH) demonstrates a statistically significant greater improvement in all primary outcomes at 3 months and 2 years in patients who underwent surgery compared to those who received nonoperative treatment.

However, the analysis of the RTC cohort failed to show a significant difference based on the intent-to-treat principle due to significant patient crossover. Nonetheless, the as-treated analysis at 4 and 8 years revealed statistically significant greater improvements in patients who received surgical treatment compared to those who received nonoperative treatment.

Surgical treatment results in a significantly greater improvement in patients compared to nonoperative treatment. A greater treatment effect (TE) is associated with being married, experiencing a deteriorating symptom trend at baseline, the absence of joint problems, older age, no worker’s compensation, longer symptom duration, high school education or less, and an SF-36 mental component score less than 35.

Patients without joint problems or diabetes, those who were married, and those who experienced worsening symptoms at baseline demonstrated a greater improvement with surgical intervention. Surgical intervention yields significantly better outcomes for other groups of patients as well.

For instance, patients who have sequestered fragments visible on Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), patients who present with higher levels of baseline back pain and radiculopathy, those with symptoms that have persisted for a longer period of time, and those who were not employed or disabled at the start of the study.


Although obese patients may not experience the same degree of benefit from surgical or non-surgical treatment as non-obese patients, both of them can still experience significant improvements in outcomes with surgical treatment.

Moreover, there are no significant differences in complications such as intraoperative dural tear, spinal fluid leak, nerve root injury, postoperative nerve root injury, wound hematoma, and wound infection between obese and non-obese patients. Surgery duration and hospital stay are slightly extended.


Patients with upper lumbar herniations had significantly greater treatment effect from surgical treatment than patients with L5-S1 herniations for the BP, PF subscales, and ODI at 2 years. When comparing the treatment effect (TE) of surgery between L4-L5 and L5-S, the difference is only significant for the PF subscale.

The treatment effect is the smallest at the L5-S1 level, with intermediate effects at L4-L5, and the largest effects at the L2-L3 and L3-L4 levels, as observed in the data. The variation in improvement between different levels is attributed to the fact that patients with upper lumbar herniations have less improvement after nonoperative treatment.

Symptoms and Pain

Patients who experience symptoms for a duration of six months or more prior to treatment exhibit significantly worse primary outcomes, irrespective of the type of treatment received, whether surgical or nonoperative.

To anticipate possible outcomes, it is necessary to assess several factors, including the recurrence of symptoms, time taken for initial symptom resolution, sociodemographics, clinical characteristics, work-related factors, herniation characteristics detected through imaging, and the level of pain at baseline.


Patients who have L5-S1 IDH on MRI and undergo L5-S1 discectomy have shown that those with retrolisthesis have significantly worse BP and PF outcomes over a 4-year period, but no significant differences were found in ODI or SBI.

Furthermore, retrolisthesis does not have a significant impact on factors such as operative time, blood loss, length of hospital stay, incidence of complications, the likelihood of additional spine surgeries, or recurrence of intervertebral disc herniation. Patients with retrolisthesis have worse postoperative outcomes.

Previous Treatments’ Effects

In terms of patient preferences, surgery was preferred by patients who did not receive an injection. Patients do not experience any improvement in their outcomes in the short or long term. Patients who underwent injections were more likely to switch to non-surgical treatment, but this may be due to their greater reluctance to undergo surgery.

Opioid Medications

Opioid users demonstrate significantly worse baseline scores in both primary and secondary outcomes, as well as a higher number of patients reporting the perception of worsening symptoms and neurological deficits.

More opioid patients receive surgery compared to non-opioid patients. The use of opioid medications is linked to a higher likelihood of transitioning to surgical treatment and a lower likelihood of avoiding surgery. A decline in pain and quality of life is observed among individuals who use opioids.
Incidental Durotomy

Patients who experienced durotomy have significantly longer operative duration, increased blood loss during surgery, and a longer inpatient stay. Nevertheless, there are no disparities in the frequency of nerve root damage, postoperative death, supplementary surgeries, or in scores of BP, PF, or ODI at 1, 2, 3, or 4 years for patients who had durotomy.

Intra- and Inter-Reader Reliability of MRI Parameters

The classification of disc morphology shows significant intra- and inter-reader agreement, but there is only moderate reliability among readers when it comes to the assessment of thecal sac and nerve root compression.

Furthermore, quantitative measurements of canal and thecal sac area show good reliability. However, there is only modest reliability in measuring the area of the disc fragment. Clinical spine specialists and radiologists demonstrate excellent agreement in the identification of herniation level and location within the level when comparing MRI readings.


Risk factors for reherniation include younger age, absence of sensory and motor deficits, and higher baseline ODI scores. At the 8-year mark, the reoperation rate of patients who underwent surgery and were included in SPORT study is 15%. Reasons for reoperation included recurrent IDH (62%), complication or other factor (25%), and new condition (11%). Patients who were older and presented with asymmetric motor weakness were less likely to undergo reoperation.

Clinical Centers Impact

Variations are observed across centers in terms of patient age, race, baseline disability levels, and treatment preferences, leading to significant differences. Additionally, unadjusted reoperation rates differed across centers.

The rates of reoperation that are not adjusted for other factors also differed between centers. Although there are significant variations in the length of surgery, blood loss, and the incidence of durotomy across the centers, the long-term outcomes remain the same.

A greater number of patients showed a preference for surgical treatment. Younger patients with lower education levels and higher rates of unemployment or disability are more likely to prefer operative treatment.

Furthermore, these patients exhibited greater levels of pain, poorer physical and mental functioning, increased disability related to back pain, longer duration of symptoms, and higher usage of opioids. Patients who opt for physical therapy (PT) as a conservative treatment have higher disability scores and neurological deficits.

Patient Expectations

Patient expectations, especially their belief in the effectiveness of non-surgical treatment, is the most significant predictor of improvement with conservative management. This is also the main factor that influences the patient’s decision to choose surgery.

Patient expectations and preferences are significantly associated with other characteristics such as demographic factors, functional status, and prior treatment experience. Irrespective of the treatment modality chosen (surgical or non-surgical), patients with low expectations of surgery have poorer outcomes.

Conversely, those with high expectations of conservative treatment had better outcomes with non-surgical management. Positive associations with outcomes are clinically significant when patients have high expectations of either treatment.

Educational Level

Conservative management leads to significantly greater overall improvement over 4 years in BP, PF, and ODI for patients with higher levels of education. The effectiveness of surgery was reduced due to the successful nonoperative treatment in these patients.

Furthermore, higher levels of education were found to be significantly linked with greater improvement in nonoperative treatment, but not in operative outcomes. In addition, the success of nonoperative treatment in such patients led to a decrease in the comparative advantage of surgery.

If you are interested in knowing more about Outcomes Following 10-year mark of Spine patient uutcomes research trial for Intervertebral Disc Herniation you have come to the right place!

Call Us Now!

Based on 107 reviews
Dr. Nakul Karkare is awesome! And patriotic! Thank you, Dr. Karkare for displaying the American Flag in your waiting room, honoring and mourning our military personnel, this Memorial Day, who died while serving in the United States Armed Forces.
00:52 30 May 23
Excellent and skilled orthopedic practice specializing in joint replacements. Dr Karkare was trained at the Hospital for Special Surgery and has excellent results, as do his associates!! Would gladly refer family members to the practice!!
00:24 30 May 23
I had such a wonderful experience with Complete Orthopedics in Stony Brook. Not only did Dr. Kuo fix my broken wrist with such kindness and care, but the office staff, including Billing, Reception and the X-Ray Technician, was always so helpful, going out of their way to ensure that each patient felt welcome, answering any questions with a smile, and ensuring any issues with insurance/billing were handled with the utmost professionalism. I highly recommend their practice!
Victoria DeMatteo
19:49 10 May 23
I'm very happy St. Catherine's sent me to this office for treatment after I broke my collar bone! Unfortunately the break was too severe to repair on its own and I had to have it rebuilt a week after the injury. Dr. Vaksha did a great job fixing it. I'm three months out, and I have full use of the arm and shoulder. The whole office staff is very professional, accommodating, and welcoming. I hope to not need orthopedic services again, but Dr. Vaksha will be my number one choice if I or anyone in family suffers such am injury.
Tina Rivera
20:42 08 May 23
No one likes going to the doctor. But these people make it painless. I go for knees, hips and shoulders. At almost 70 Complete Orthopedics keeps my active life style running smoothly. Whether chasing my Grandson and even surfing again, I highly recommend them!!
Thomas Slavin
15:02 02 Mar 23
Dr. Kuo knowledgeable and competent surgeon- very good experience and more importantly great result.
Joseph McCoy
21:23 25 Feb 23
Dr Vaksha was so kind and helpful. He took extra time with us and explained things so thoroughly. Highly recommend. Office very clean.
Susan Bosinius
20:20 19 Feb 23
Dr Vaksha, is a great doctor very professional knows what he talking about. Treat patient with upmost respect. Thank You
Troy Spencer
16:46 19 Jan 23
Dr. Karkare is an amazing doctor, very caring and attentive, the girl at the front desk is very kind and helpful. .elizabeth .thank you so much .
blanca ventura
21:32 26 Oct 22
Been going to this place before my accident and after I had my knee surgery. So happy how I been treated and how well I am getting. Thank you all and specially Dr. VAKSHA for everything and getting back on track.
Ita Opico
19:01 25 Oct 22
Love this place From the minute I called I was treated kindly. When I arrived The Dr saw me right away he was compassionate and ordered the appropriate tests for me. I came back in for my follow up and had the same great experience.
Christine Rostock
21:28 23 May 22
Dr Vaksha and Dr karkare are 2 of the best orthopedic doctors around my wife Susan had a very serious broken ankle in March of 2019 she didn't think she was going to walk again Dr vaksha did an excellent surgery on her ankle he said it was his toughest he ever did he put a lot of hardware in her ankle and told her she would be alright she made remarkable recovery thanks to his surgery as of now she regained 100 percent use of her ankle she would highly recommend him to anyone. My own experience with Dr karkare has been wonderful he takes his time with you listens to what you have to say and prescribes various treatments and is very caring I would highly recommend him to anyone I would give both doctors a 10 plus rating we are very happy with them the best.
Harry Jones
23:31 19 May 22
Complete orthopedics is a wonderful place to go when you hurt or injured a great staff and wonderful doctors very knowledgeable and helpful I would recommend this place to all of my family and friends that is in me of orthopedic care I give them 10 thumbs up
Wayne Pemberton
17:39 18 May 22
The staff is very professional and helpful. Dr. Vaksha is excellent. He takes time to listen and offer suggestions to help you get better. I’m very thankful and happy to be a patient here at Complete Orthopedics.
Phoenix Rising
19:54 16 May 22
Dr.Karkare is the best. He listens to everything and explains everything I recommend him to everyone. I am so happy he is my doctor.
Myrna James
00:48 13 May 22
Dr.Kuo is amazing very attentive,caring,and passionate and staff is awsome too.Thank you for everything Dr.kuo.
Erick Murillo
23:17 12 May 22
I was in a car accident November 1 I was referred to Dr. Vaksha For shoulder surgery . I he was amazing he made me feel very comfortable and explained everything that was going to happen from surgery all the way through my physical therapy highly recommend Dr. Vaksha
Yolanda Ojeda
19:37 09 May 22
My appointment with Dr. Vaksha was amazing. Dr. Vaksha was very thorough and kind. I would refer this office to anyone who needs a great orthopedic doctor.
John Senechal
19:54 05 May 22
Scheduling my appointment was quick and easy. The staff was super friendly and down to earth. I was seen on time. The appropriate test, “x-rays” were taken before the conversation with doctor, something I really liked, test for analysis and conversation was done upfront. Dr. V had a great personality and was no BS, straight forward diagnosis and a play on next steps. I am happy I found them and would refer them to friends and family.
00:46 03 May 22
I have seen Dr. Kuo two times already and he's awesome along with his staff. Very friendly office and I'm glad to be a patient here.
Camaris A
20:01 28 Apr 22
Amazing team!! Very caring, profesional, and friendly!! Dr. Kevin Kuo, you are the best, very passionate, caring, and helping thank you for getting me better and being so kind to me! Elizabeth you the best thank you for you help always and you big smile and positive actitud❤️🙏🏼
breidy valerio
19:01 22 Apr 22
The staff is truly exceptional, they make you feel comfortable and welcomed. The doctors are amazing,always professional, compassionate and great listeners.
Elizabeth Collado
03:25 09 Apr 22
What a great place! The place is clean and organized.The staff is wonderful. Setting up physical therapy is right there as well.I'm so glad I found this place.
Donna Anne
22:45 05 Apr 22
This was my 1st time breaking something in my 27 years on this planet. I was recommended here by a friend Dr. Vashka helped me from day 1 and still continues to check in on me and my healing ankle. Would highly recommend
tyron davis
16:06 01 Apr 22
Brand new office, same great doctors! Rooms are clean, plenty of parking, physical therapy attached, Dr. Karkare and his staff are awesome. Thank you!
Emily B
02:49 24 Mar 22
Dr.VAksha is the best, I love the way he treats me as his patient, he is caring,understanding and very attentive to my needs
Mirna Caballero
14:53 03 Mar 22
Great staff. Dr. Vaksha is awesome and takes the time to listen to his patients. He is very compassionate. I would highly recommend this office.
Bebe Doyle
01:24 23 Feb 22
After suffering from a severe ankle injury Dr. V was able to help me heal and return back to work completely to a job where I stand for 12 hours a day. The office is very clean and I appreciated the reminders of my appointments via phone call and through text. The patient portal made it easy for me to access all my documents including work notes. The office staff is wonderful and Rebecca was able to schedule me with a busy schedule and awesome at answering all of my questions including referring me to a great physical therapy office. I highly recommend this office to anyone who’s looking for knowledgeable and kind orthopedic office.
Elizabeth Birchwell
21:31 28 Jan 21
The staff here are great, I was seen at the time of my appointment and was well taken care of!
Shaun Berry
18:14 07 Jan 21
They are an excellent practice. The front and back office people are amazing and so helpful. Rebecca is such a kind and understanding person. I had an issue with paperwork and she cleared it right up. Dr. Karkare is very knowledgeable, helpful, and caring.
Matt S.
19:31 18 Nov 20
Rebecca K. - What a true burst of sunshine. Very friendly and definitely an asset to the practice!
Laura Aston
18:17 17 Nov 20
Great experience, the Doctor is nice but the staff is incredible. I worked with Linda, who was profession and assisted me beyond what any person has done at other practices. Complete Ortho should be complimented for having such a person on their staff.I highly recommend this place!!!
Joe Allen
17:26 17 Nov 20
Linda and Becca they are so good ever time I come they are very nice I would tell everyone I no to come to this office..
Barbara Victor
16:45 17 Nov 20
I was rear ended in an auto accident , Dr Vashka was recommended by a friend of mine .I was experiencing Back , neck , and shoulder pain . After a thorough examination and given exercises to do at home , I am feeling much better , and I ended up avoiding surgery . The staff at Complete Ortho is extremely attentive and show great care when making an appointment and are very friendly and i never waited more than 5 minutes for my appointment . So I would strongly recommend Complete Orthopedics for any aches and pains that one might be experiencing.....
Bill Becht
04:44 17 Nov 20
It was the afternoon of Friday Sept. 24. We were in Pt. Jefferson and my wife, Mary Ann, broke her hip. We went to Mather Hospital and it was determined that she would have to have an operation to have it repaired. This would be her third time under the knife in the past year. It just so happened that we were very fortunate enough to have Dr. Karkare, who was on standby, perform the surgery. He put in a rod and two screws in her hip. She spent a few days in the hospital and then went to Gurwin rehabilitee for another few weeks.It has now been almost six weeks and we both worked the election the other day. If it wasn’t for Dr. Karkare’s expertise she never would have been able to work. She is able to walk with a walker and is doing physical therapy three times a week.We can not thank the doctor enough for the compassion and dedication that he puts into his work. It allows Mary Ann do the things that she likes to do, even on a limited basis for a while. I know that with her will, perseverance and the great work that the surgeon performed she will be back on her feet in no time.Sincerely:John V. PlumpEast Northport, NY 11731
Jack Harris
14:36 06 Nov 20
In the year of 2018 I was referred to Dr. Karkare because I was experiencing severe knee joint pain. After exhausting physical therapy and trying to labor through the pain, I had to make a quality of life decision. Total knee replacement was the only viable option. Dr. Karkare made my decision easy as he walked me through the whole process from surgery to recovery.On 12/13/19 ( Friday the 13th) I enter Lenox Hill Hospital in great hands. From the time I entered Dr. Karkare’s office for the first time until now, his staff has been amazing. Andrea the medical coordinator walked me through all the paper work and necessary preparations for the surgery. Courtesy and kind would be an understatement. Dr. Karkare went over and beyond from the wellness checks and phone calls all to assure me that I was important to him. This was the right decision no pain and no limp. Complete Orthopedics should be your choice!
Kenneth Randolph
22:18 25 Sep 20
Dr. Vadshka has a great bedside manner. He really takes his time and explains treatment options.
T Lee
12:33 09 Sep 20
I suffered with pain in both knees for years. My orthopedic doctor kept recommending knee replacement . I fought it for years, as I was just afraid. When I had no choice and could barely walk , it was recommended I see Dr. Karkare. We set up a consultation and my wife and I left his office feeling totally confident and comfortable with moving ahead with the surgery. He explained everything to us, and the office staff set everything up for us and made the process easy. So about one month after our initial meeting I had the first knee done. I was up walking mere hours after the surgery, and on the workout machines the next morning. I went home two days after the surgery, and yes walked my daughter down the aisle at her wedding only one week after the surgery without even a cane! Three months later I had the other knee done and went home the very next day. Dr. Karkare put my fears to rest . I would highly recommend him. His expertise gave me my life back. Thank you Dr. Karkare.SincerelyVito Congro
Ethel Congo
23:58 12 Aug 20
Dr Rhodin really cares for his patients. When I see him he makes sure to review my progress in detail.
Micki Cahill
15:03 08 Feb 20
My mom had a total hip replacement by dr karkare. He is the BEST orthopedic doctor.Her incision is almost invisable.She is going back for her other hip next week. The office staff is the best, love Andrea.You wont find a better doctor.
Ryan Brigandi
21:06 13 Jul 18
There is no better Orthopedic doctor you will find. Broke my ankle three places on a Saturday. Called Dr. Karkare. He had is team ready at the hospital and operated on me within 6 hours after my injury. Now After 3 months of great care by him and his staff, I am walking to normalcy.
Spacecom Tel
04:13 23 Mar 18

I am Vedant Vaksha, Fellowship trained Spine, Sports and Arthroscopic Surgeon at Complete Orthopedics. I take care of patients with ailments of the neck, back, shoulder, knee, elbow and ankle. I personally approve this content and have written most of it myself.

Please take a look at my profile page and don't hesitate to come in and talk.